Katy_Metz_cross_examined.jpg

Courtroom Sketch

Creator
The New York Times
Date(s)
1889

Courtroom sketches in the United States date back as early as the late nineteenth century. These courtroom drawings were created at time when photography was not a practical option for courtroom – even now, many jurisdictions do not allow cameras so as to prevent distractions for lawyers and to preserve the privacy of defendants. Most courtroom sketch artists work against the clock to produce viable images of plaintiffs, defendants, judges, and lawyers, even if subjects may only appear for a few minutes in the courtroom. In places like the United Kingdom, sketch artists are not allowed to draw during the proceedings and must retain the visual scenes and draw from memory. New media, thus, has to rely on sketch artists to depict legal proceedings. Many of these sketch drawings were reproduced in print publications as engravings as well, circulated for public consumption. According to art historian Marc H. Miller, overtime, a natural market developed for these sketches, especially in the legal profession, especially if sketches of a particular case had a connection to a firm. The appeal of courtroom sketches also lay in its historical and exclusive nature; once trials are over, the original sketches cannot be found anywhere else. The sketches are somewhere between fine and commercia art, but some suggest that these courtroom sketches also turn criminal trials into generic and anachronistic images – sometimes described as the most conventionalized form in visual media.

Sources
Bryson Taylor, Derrick. 2021. "The Courtroom Sketch: A Piece Of History, And Art." Nytimes.com. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/07/us/courtroom-sketch-value.html.

"Drawing Justice: The Art Of Courtroom Illustration | Exhibitions At The Library Of Congress | Library Of Congress." 2021. The Library Of Congress. https://www.loc.gov/exhibitions/drawing-justice-courtroom-illustrations/about-this-exhibition/.

Freeman, Michael. 2005. "Courtroom Sketching: Reflections On History, Law And The Image 1." In Law And Popular Culture, 173-182. Oxford: Oxford Scholarship Online. https://oxford.universitypressscholarship.com/view/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199272235.001.0001/acprof-9780199272235-chapter-10.

Image Credit:

New York Times Courtroom Sketch Of Katy Metz Under Cross Examination During The Trial Of Ex-Alderman Thomas Cleary. 1889. Sketch. New York City: Historical and Public Figures Archives - New York Public Library Archives.
Files